Correctness, Harmfulness, and Diversity of Large Language Models for Colonoscopy Preparation Assistance: Comparative Evaluation Study.
Authors: Kaumenova T, Chakraborty S, Fosler-Lussier E, Gofar K, Metcalf I, Perrault A, White M
Journal: JMIR AI
mental health
psychology
open access
Abstract
Motor neuron disease (MND), also known as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), is a progressive neurological condition characterized by the degeneration of motor neurons, leading to progressive muscle weakness in the limbs and affecting speech and swallowing, significantly impacting physical, emotional, and social functioning []. The prevalence of MND is approximately 8.58 per 100,000 []. It is a rapidly progressive condition, with a median life expectancy of 2 to 3 years from diagnosis, with death typically resulting from respiratory failure []. MND causes rapidly changing complexities; as the condition advances, the requirement for support grows exponentially []. Many individuals experience cognitive impairments—specifically executive dysfunction and language deficits—with a significant proportion developing frontotemporal dementia []. These combined physical and cognitive challenges heighten the need for specialist interventions. Consequently, the multifaceted nature of the disease necessitates a multidisciplinary approach to address its various clinical elements [,]. The team may include neurologists, physiotherapists, occupational therapists, specialist nurses, social workers, dietitians, speech and language therapists, respiratory nurses, and palliative care specialists []. While clinical practice guidelines advocate coordinated care delivered by specialist multidisciplinary teams to improve quality of life and longevity, the practical implementation of this model faces systemic challenges [-]. The relatively low prevalence of MND has necessitated a model in which patients travel to centralized specialist clinics staffed by a team of MND specialist health care professionals, but between appointments, they rely on nonspecialist community health and social care professionals for day-to-day support []. The geographic distance between specialist centers and community services, along with the involvement of multiple distinct organizations, often results in communication challenges and significant barriers to collaborative working. Uncoordinated care can impose emotional, physical, and financial burdens and can be time-consuming for people living with MND, their carers, and the health care professionals involved in their care [,]. Poor communication in MND care can result in organizations operating in isolation, unaware of who is responsible for specific patient needs []. Simultaneously, our patient and public involvement and engagement group, which we formed to support the development of this study, identified that the multitude of specialists involved can lead to role confusion, making it difficult for patients to navigate or remember their own care network. Furthermore, the relative rarity and challenges of MND often result in community-based health and social care professionals lacking the specialized knowledge required to manage complex interventions, such as gastrostomy, advanced care planning, and respiratory support [,]. Consequently, these practitioners rely on the expertise of specialist teams—support that is not always readily accessible. To ensure high-quality care, 2-way communication between MND specialist centers and nonspecialist community teams, patients, their families, and carers is required. Without seamless access to specialist expertise, there is a risk of poor care outcomes and increased emotional stressors for both providers and families [,]. These deficiencies are often most acute for underserved communities, including those in rural areas or those facing socioeconomic barriers to accessing centralized specialist services []. While previous research has established the urgent need for better care coordination, there remains a lack of specific, evidence-based interventions for achieving this within the current health and social care infrastructure. A coordinated care system would lead to better outcomes and care for people living with MND and their carers. The MND Together project aims to address this gap by co-designing a practical care coordination tool to improve the quality of care and ensure that expert MND support is accessible as close to every patient’s home as possible. This approach aligns with the strategic shifts outlined in the National Health Service (NHS) 10-year plan, specifically the transition from hospital to community []. The project will use a 4-workstream approach to co-design and evaluate this tool. This protocol will focus on the first 3 workstreams, which represent the development phase.